Maryland Criminal Appeals and Post-Conviction Lawyer
A conviction or a sentence is not always the last word in a criminal case. Maryland and federal law both provide ways to ask a higher court, or the sentencing court itself, to look at what happened again. Each of those routes has its own deadline, and several of the deadlines are short enough to expire before a family has finished absorbing the verdict. At Walsh-Little Law, David Walsh-Little handles criminal appeals and post-conviction matters arising from the Maryland state courts and from the United States District Court for the District of Maryland.
David Walsh-Little spent over a decade with the Maryland Office of the Public Defender, including three years as chief of the felony trial division in the Baltimore City office, and more than four years as an assistant federal public defender. Appellate work starts from the trial record, and his career has been spent on the defense side of the courtrooms where those records are made.
The First Question Is Which Deadline Applies
Appellate and post-conviction work starts with the calendar, not the merits. The time limits below are set by statute or court rule, and missing one can close a route entirely, however strong the underlying issue may be.
- Notice of appeal from a circuit court judgment: 30 days after entry of the judgment, under Maryland Rule 8-202.
- Appeal from the District Court of Maryland: 30 days from the date of the final judgment, under section 12-401 of the Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article.
- Application for leave to appeal after a guilty plea in circuit court: 30 days, under Rule 8-204.
- Motion for a new trial: 10 days after the verdict, with longer periods for newly discovered evidence, under Rule 4-331.
- Application for review of a sentence by a three-judge panel: 30 days after the sentence, under Rule 4-344.
- Motion to modify or reduce a sentence: 90 days after the sentence, under Rule 4-345.
- Notice of appeal in a federal criminal case: 14 days after entry of the judgment, under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 4(b).
Several of these run at the same time, most from the sentencing date (the motion for a new trial runs from the verdict), and filing one does not necessarily extend the time for another. Rule 4-344 states expressly that an application for sentence review does not extend the time for taking an appeal, so pursuing one route does not by itself preserve another.
Appeals From the District Court Are Heard Again From the Start
Many misdemeanors and traffic offenses in Maryland are tried in the District Court, which hears cases without a jury; under section 4-302 of the Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article, the District Court loses jurisdiction when a defendant who is entitled to a jury trial demands one. An appeal from a District Court criminal judgment is filed with the District Court clerk and goes to the circuit court for the same county. In a criminal case it is generally tried de novo, meaning the case is heard again as a new trial rather than reviewed for legal error. The statute applies that rule even where the District Court sentence followed a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
Because the circuit court hears the case fresh, the appeal can carry a right to a jury trial where the offense is subject to a penalty of imprisonment. Once a notice of appeal is filed, the circuit court may also stay a District Court jail sentence and release the defendant pending the new trial. Whether a de novo appeal makes sense depends on how the case went the first time and on what a second hearing is likely to involve. Under section 12-702(c) of the Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article, a circuit court that convicts after a de novo trial may impose a more severe sentence than the District Court did, which is part of that assessment.
Appeals From the Circuit Court Go to the Appellate Court of Maryland
Jury trials take place in the circuit courts, along with cases charged there by indictment or criminal information. Under section 12-301 of the Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article, a defendant may appeal a final judgment entered by a circuit court even where imposition or execution of the sentence was suspended. That appeal goes to the Appellate Court of Maryland, which was called the Court of Special Appeals until December 2022.
Further review in the Supreme Court of Maryland, formerly the Court of Appeals, is by petition for a writ of certiorari. That court grants review where it finds review desirable and in the public interest, so a second level of appeal is discretionary rather than automatic. A petition is due no later than the later of 15 days after the Appellate Court issues its mandate or 30 days after that court files its opinion.
A circuit court appeal is a review of the record, not a new trial. The appellate court reads the transcript and the filings, considers written briefs, and decides whether a legal error occurred and whether it mattered. It does not hear new witnesses, and in a case tried without a jury it gives due regard to the trial judge's opportunity to assess the credibility of the witnesses.
Preservation: What Was Said at Trial Shapes What Can Be Raised
Maryland Rule 8-131 provides that, apart from questions of jurisdiction, an appellate court ordinarily will not decide an issue unless it plainly appears by the record to have been raised in or decided by the trial court. In practical terms, an objection that was never made, or a motion that was never filed, is generally difficult to raise for the first time on appeal.
That is why appellate work is so closely tied to what happened in the courtroom. The transcript is the case on appeal. Reading it in full, including the bench conferences, the jury instructions and the sentencing hearing, is where the issues are found, and sometimes where it becomes clear that an issue that seemed promising was not preserved.
Appellate issues can arise from rulings admitting or excluding evidence, the denial of a motion to suppress, the jury instructions, the sufficiency of the evidence, and the sentence itself. Whether any of those is present depends entirely on the record in the particular case.
A Guilty Plea Changes the Route
A guilty plea in circuit court does not carry an ordinary appeal. Under section 12-302(e) of the Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article, review of a judgment entered after a guilty plea in circuit court is sought by application for leave to appeal, which the Appellate Court may grant or deny. The application is due within 30 days after entry of the judgment.
The statute makes one exception. A conditional plea of guilty, in which the defendant preserves in writing the pretrial issues he or she intends to appeal, may be appealed in accordance with the Maryland Rules. Where a suppression ruling is the heart of a case, whether a conditional plea is available is a question worth raising before a plea is entered rather than afterwards.
Reviews
David is a great lawyer to work with. He's very attentive and on top of things. He cares about his clients and is very knowledgeable. Thank you, David
I recommend David's criminal defense and DWI defense services.
Baltimore criminal defense lawyer David Walsh-Little first came to my attention over 25 years ago, when I learned about his legal assistance to Plowshares activists. Since that time, I have occasionally communicated with him and then talked with David in depth on my podcast.
I can confidently recommend criminal defendants to David for Maryland matters for which I do not offer assistance.
Post-Conviction Relief Under the Uniform Postconviction Procedure Act
Post-conviction relief is not an appeal. It is a separate proceeding, filed in the circuit court for the county where the conviction took place, and it can reach problems the trial record does not show. Maryland's Uniform Postconviction Procedure Act, in Title 7 of the Criminal Procedure Article, governs it.
The Act applies to a person convicted in a Maryland court who is confined under a sentence of imprisonment or is on parole or probation. A petition may claim that the sentence or judgment was imposed in violation of the United States Constitution or the Constitution or laws of Maryland, that the court lacked jurisdiction, that the sentence exceeds the maximum allowed by law, or that the sentence is otherwise subject to collateral attack. The alleged error must not have been previously and finally litigated or waived.
Two limits shape the strategy. Under section 7-103, a person may file only one petition for each trial or sentence, and unless extraordinary cause is shown, a petition may not be filed more than 10 years after the sentence was imposed. Because only one petition is allowed, the claims need to be identified as fully as possible. A petition can be amended before it is decided, and a concluded proceeding can be reopened where the court finds that doing so is in the interests of justice under section 7-104. After the circuit court rules, an aggrieved party may apply to the Appellate Court of Maryland for leave to appeal within 30 days, under section 7-109.
A claim about the performance of trial counsel is the kind of issue this proceeding is designed to reach, because whether counsel investigated, advised and performed adequately can depend on facts that never appear in the trial transcript.
Other Routes After a Conviction
Several further remedies exist for specific situations, each with its own requirements.
Sentence review by a three-judge panel. Under sections 8-102 and 8-105 of the Criminal Procedure Article, a person convicted in circuit court and sentenced to more than two years is entitled to a single review by a panel of three or more circuit court judges, not including the sentencing judge. The application is due within 30 days. The panel may leave the sentence unchanged, but it may also order a different sentence, including an increased one, which is why this route is weighed carefully rather than filed automatically.
Motion to modify or reduce a sentence. Under Rule 4-345(e), a motion filed within 90 days after the sentence gives the court revisory power over it for up to five years from the date the sentence was originally imposed. That power does not include the ability to increase the sentence. For motions filed on or after October 1, 2026, the rule adds a procedure for requesting a hearing and a decision before the five-year period runs out.
Correcting an illegal sentence. Rule 4-345(a) allows the court to correct an illegal sentence at any time.
Newly discovered evidence. A motion for a new trial based on newly discovered evidence that could not have been found with due diligence in time for the 10-day motion may be filed within one year after the later of the date the sentence was imposed or the date the mandate from the final appellate court was issued, with an exception for certain DNA and scientific evidence, under Rule 4-331(c). Separately, a person convicted of a crime triable in circuit court may file a petition for writ of actual innocence at any time under section 8-301 of the Criminal Procedure Article, where newly discovered evidence meets the statutory standard.
Coram nobis. Because post-conviction relief under the Act is limited to people who are confined or on parole or probation, a petition for writ of error coram nobis can matter to someone whose sentence is finished but whose conviction continues to carry significant collateral consequences, such as an immigration or licensing consequence. Under Rule 15-1202, the petition is filed in the court where the conviction took place and must describe those consequences and explain why appeal and post-conviction relief are unavailable. Coram nobis attacks the conviction itself, which makes it a different remedy from Maryland expungement, where eligible records are removed from public view.
Federal Appeals and Post-Conviction Motions
Federal convictions follow a separate track. A defendant's notice of appeal in a federal criminal case must be filed in the district court within 14 days after the later of the entry of the judgment or the government's notice of appeal. Appeals from the District of Maryland are heard by the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, which sits in Richmond.
Because the sentencing hearing produces part of the record a federal appeal relies on, how the guidelines were argued during federal sentencing can shape what is available to raise later.
After a federal conviction becomes final, a motion under 28 U.S.C. 2255 allows a person in custody to ask the sentencing court to vacate, set aside or correct a sentence imposed in violation of the Constitution or laws of the United States. A one-year limitation period applies, generally running from the date the judgment became final, with defined exceptions. The Supreme Court held in Massaro v. United States that a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel may be brought in a section 2255 proceeding whether or not it could have been raised on direct appeal.
How the Process Works
Whichever route applies, the work generally moves through the same stages.
- Securing the deadline. Where a notice of appeal or an application is due, it is filed first, because the substantive work can follow but the filing date cannot move.
- Obtaining the record. Transcripts of every hearing, the exhibits, the docket and the charging documents are ordered and reviewed in full.
- Identifying the issues. The record is read for preserved errors, and the case is examined for matters outside the record that may support a post-conviction claim.
- Briefing. On appeal, the appellant files a brief setting out the legal arguments, and the State or the government responds.
- Argument and decision. The appellate court may hear oral argument before issuing a written decision. On an application for leave to appeal, the court first decides whether to allow the appeal at all.
Timelines vary with the court and the route. An appeal can take many months from the notice to a decision, and a post-conviction petition involves its own proceedings in the circuit court before any appeal from that ruling.
Why Choose David Walsh-Little as Your Maryland Criminal Appeals Attorney
David Walsh-Little's background spans both state and federal criminal defense, including years trying serious felony cases in Baltimore City and representing clients in Baltimore's federal courthouse. Appellate and post-conviction work draws directly on that trial experience, because finding an issue in a transcript depends on recognizing what should have happened in the courtroom and did not.
He is admitted to practice in Maryland and New York, before the United States District Court for the District of Maryland, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, and the United States Supreme Court, and his practice has included state post-conviction and federal habeas matters. Appeals arise from both his Maryland state criminal defense and his federal criminal defense work. He reviews the record personally, and clients work directly with him.
Serving Baltimore & Surrounding Counties
Walsh-Little Law represents clients throughout the Baltimore metropolitan area in both state and federal courts.
Frequently Asked Questions: Maryland Criminal Appeals and Post-Conviction
How long do I have to file a criminal appeal in Maryland?
Generally 30 days. A notice of appeal from a circuit court judgment is due within 30 days after entry of the judgment, and an appeal from the District Court must be filed with the District Court clerk within 30 days of the final judgment. In federal court the deadline is 14 days. These periods run from the date the judgment was entered, so the date on the docket can matter more than the date of the hearing.
Can I appeal after pleading guilty?
What is the difference between an appeal and post-conviction relief?
Can a sentence be reduced after it is imposed?
Can new evidence be considered after a conviction?
Contact a Baltimore Criminal Appeals Attorney Today, Free Consultation
The deadlines after a conviction are short, and missing one can close a route entirely. Depending on the record, there may be issues to raise on direct appeal, in a motion for a new trial or sentence review, or in a post-conviction petition.
Call Walsh-Little Law today at 410-205-9337 for a free, confidential consultation. David will review your case, explain your options, and start building a defense from day one.
- Monday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Tuesday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Wednesday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Thursday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Friday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Saturday Closed
- Sunday Closed
Email Us
We look forward to receiving your questions and comments and will reply to your email promptly.
* Required Field
"*" indicates required fields
Disclaimer: The Law Office of David Walsh-Little is a Maryland Limited Liability Company established for the practice of law. The information on this website is for general information only. The content on this site is not legal advice and should not be construed as such. Visitors to this site should not rely on its content when making legal decisions. Access to the information on this website is not intended to, and does not create, an attorney-client relationship between the Law Office of David Walsh-Little, LLC and any other person or entity.