Maryland Grand Jury Investigations Lawyer
A grand jury subpoena, or a letter from a federal prosecutor describing someone as a target, can be the first sign that an investigation has been under way for some time. The documents are short and formal, and they tend to raise more questions than they answer: what the investigation is about, whether the recipient is a witness or something more, and what the obligations are. At Walsh-Little Law, David Walsh-Little represents witnesses, subjects and targets in federal grand jury investigations in the District of Maryland and in Maryland state grand jury matters.
David Walsh-Little spent over a decade with the Maryland Office of the Public Defender, including three years as chief of the felony trial division in the Baltimore City office, and more than four years as an assistant federal public defender. Grand juries operate in both of those systems, under different rules.
What a Grand Jury Is and What It Is Not
A grand jury is a body of citizens that hears evidence presented by prosecutors and decides whether to return an indictment. It does not decide guilt, and it is not an adversary proceeding. It also has substantial investigative power, exercised through subpoenas for testimony and records, and an investigation can run for months before anyone is charged.
Its proceedings are closed. In federal court, only government attorneys, the witness being questioned, interpreters when needed, and a court reporter or recording operator may be present while the grand jury is in session, under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(d). Maryland Rule 4-642 contains an equivalent list for state grand juries: attorneys for the State, the witness, a court reporter and, when needed, an interpreter. In neither system does a witness's lawyer sit in the room during the testimony.
Federal and Maryland Grand Juries Work Differently
Both systems use grand juries, but the grand jury plays a different role in each, and it matters which one issued the subpoena.
The Federal Grand Jury
The Fifth Amendment provides that no person shall be held to answer for a capital or otherwise infamous crime unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 7 carries that into practice: an offense punishable by death or by imprisonment for more than one year must be prosecuted by indictment, unless the defendant waives indictment in open court and agrees to proceed by information.
A federal grand jury has 16 to 23 members, and at least 12 must concur to return an indictment. A grand jury may serve more than 18 months only if the court finds an extension is in the public interest, and an extension may be granted for no more than six months except as otherwise provided by statute. Beyond its charging role, a federal grand jury compels testimony and documents before anyone is charged, which is how it functions as an investigative tool.
The Maryland Grand Jury
In Maryland, a sworn grand jury consists of 23 grand jurors, plus alternates, under section 8-412 of the Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article, and a county administrative judge may summon additional grand juries on petition of a State's Attorney under section 8-413. In Baltimore City, each grand jury must also carry out an investigation when a circuit court judge directs, and report on its investigations at the end of its term, under section 8-417.
Maryland does not require a grand jury for every felony. Under sections 4-102 and 4-103 of the Criminal Procedure Article, a State's Attorney may also charge by criminal information, either where a defendant entitled to a preliminary hearing does not request one within 10 days after being told it is available, or where a court at a preliminary hearing finds probable cause to hold the defendant. A grand jury indictment is therefore one of two charging routes in Maryland, and a defendant who has been indicted has no absolute right to a preliminary hearing.
Maryland court files and records pertaining to criminal investigations are sealed and open to inspection only by court order, under Rule 4-642, and transcripts of grand jury testimony are kept in the custody of the State's Attorney for the exclusive use of the grand jury and the State's Attorney unless the circuit court orders otherwise, under section 8-416.
Witness, Subject or Target
The Justice Department's Justice Manual defines two terms that shape how a federal grand jury witness is treated. A target is a person as to whom the prosecutor or the grand jury has substantial evidence linking him or her to the commission of a crime and who, in the prosecutor's judgment, is a putative defendant. A subject is a person whose conduct is within the scope of the grand jury's investigation. A person who is neither is commonly described simply as a witness.
Those labels describe the prosecutor's view at a particular moment, and they can change as the evidence develops. The same distinctions come up when there is a first contact from a federal agent before any subpoena has issued.
What a Target Letter Is
A target letter is a written notice from a federal prosecutor that the recipient is a target of a grand jury investigation. Its basis is Justice Department policy rather than a statute or a court rule. Justice Manual section 9-11.153 encourages prosecutors, in appropriate cases, to notify a target a reasonable time before seeking an indictment so that the person has an opportunity to testify before the grand jury. The same section says notification would not be appropriate in clear-cut cases or where it might jeopardize the investigation, for example through the risk of flight or the destruction of evidence.
Not every target receives a letter, and the absence of a letter is not a statement about a person's status. A letter that does arrive marks a point at which the government regards the recipient as a possible defendant, and the period before an indictment is the time in which any response can be considered.
The Justice Manual also addresses a target who wishes to tell the grand jury his or her side. Section 9-11.152 notes that the prosecutor has no legal obligation to permit it, but provides that reasonable requests ordinarily should be given favorable consideration where they do not burden the grand jury, provided the witness explicitly waives the privilege against self-incrimination on the record. Whether to make that request is a significant decision in a federal investigation, because grand jury testimony is under oath, is recorded, and can be used later.
Reviews
David is a great lawyer to work with. He's very attentive and on top of things. He cares about his clients and is very knowledgeable. Thank you, David
I recommend David's criminal defense and DWI defense services.
Baltimore criminal defense lawyer David Walsh-Little first came to my attention over 25 years ago, when I learned about his legal assistance to Plowshares activists. Since that time, I have occasionally communicated with him and then talked with David in depth on my podcast.
I can confidently recommend criminal defendants to David for Maryland matters for which I do not offer assistance.
Subpoenas for Testimony and for Documents
A grand jury subpoena may require a person to testify, to produce documents and records, or both. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 17(c) allows a court, on a motion made promptly, to quash or modify a subpoena for documents if compliance would be unreasonable or oppressive. The Supreme Court has held that a grand jury subpoena challenged on relevance grounds is to be enforced unless there is no reasonable possibility that the materials sought will produce information relevant to the general subject of the investigation, which is a demanding standard for the person challenging it.
Much of the work on a document subpoena can therefore involve discussing scope, timing and the handling of privileged material with the prosecutor rather than litigating it. Under Justice Department policy, an Advice of Rights form is appended to grand jury subpoenas served on subjects and targets, so whether one is attached is itself informative.
Corruptly altering, destroying, mutilating or concealing a record with the intent to impair its integrity or availability for use in an official proceeding, which by statute includes a federal grand jury proceeding, is a separate federal crime under 18 U.S.C. 1512(c), punishable by up to 20 years, entirely apart from whatever the grand jury is investigating.
The Fifth Amendment Before a Grand Jury
A grand jury witness keeps the privilege against self-incrimination. The Justice Department's Advice of Rights states that the witness may refuse to answer any question if a truthful answer would tend to incriminate, that anything the witness says may be used against him or her by the grand jury or in a later proceeding, and that a witness who has an attorney will be given a reasonable opportunity to step outside the grand jury room to consult with counsel. A target receives the additional warning that his or her conduct is being investigated for possible violation of federal criminal law.
The privilege reaches documents only in a limited way. The contents of existing records that a person created voluntarily are generally not protected, but the Supreme Court has recognized that the act of producing documents can itself have a testimonial aspect, because it can communicate the existence, custody and authenticity of what is produced. A custodian of corporate records, by contrast, generally cannot resist a subpoena for the corporation's records on the ground that producing them would incriminate him personally.
Where a witness asserts the privilege, the government may seek an order compelling the testimony. Under 18 U.S.C. 6002, testimony compelled under such an order of immunity, and information directly or indirectly derived from it, may not be used against the witness in a criminal case, except in a prosecution for perjury, giving a false statement, or otherwise failing to comply with the order. Separately, knowingly making a false material declaration under oath before a grand jury is a crime under 18 U.S.C. 1623, punishable by up to five years.
Secrecy, and Who It Binds
Grand jury secrecy is real, but it does not bind everyone. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e) prohibits grand jurors, interpreters, court reporters, recording operators, transcribers, government attorneys and certain others from disclosing matters occurring before the grand jury, and it provides that no obligation of secrecy may be imposed on any other person except in accordance with the rule. A federal grand jury witness is not among the persons the rule binds. Separate federal statutes can restrict particular recipients, such as a financial institution that receives certain grand jury subpoenas for customer records. This describes the federal rule; Maryland practice is considered separately.
That does not make disclosure a sensible idea in every case. What a witness says about his or her testimony, and to whom, can have consequences in the investigation, and those questions are better worked through before the appearance than after it.
What to Expect When a Subpoena or Target Letter Arrives
- Reading the document. The subpoena identifies the court, the date to appear or produce, and what is demanded. An attached Advice of Rights form indicates that, under Justice Department policy, the recipient is regarded as a subject or a target.
- Contact with the prosecutor. Counsel may be able to learn the general subject of the investigation and the client's status, and to discuss the date and the scope of any document demand.
- Assessing exposure. Before any testimony or production, the facts are reviewed to identify any risk to the client.
- Deciding on testimony. The options can include testifying, asserting the privilege, a signed advance assertion under the Justice Manual, or an arrangement with the government. Which one fits depends on the facts.
- Preparation. Where testimony goes forward, preparation covers the subject matter, the documents, and the procedure for stepping outside to consult counsel.
- After the appearance. The investigation may continue for months. Justice Manual section 9-11.155 gives a United States Attorney discretion, but no obligation, to notify a former target that target status has ended.
Why Choose David Walsh-Little as Your Maryland Grand Jury Attorney
David Walsh-Little's background spans both state and federal criminal defense, including more than four years as an assistant federal public defender in the District of Maryland and over a decade with the Maryland Office of the Public Defender. A grand jury matter can sit in either system, and some investigations involve both, so familiarity with the Maryland courts and with Baltimore's federal courthouse both matter here.
In grand jury work, much of the value lies before anyone testifies: understanding what is being investigated, where the client fits, and which of the available responses fits the facts. Clients work directly with David from the first call. Grand jury investigations arise across the range of federal criminal defense work, including federal white collar crimes, as well as in cases handled through the firm's Maryland state criminal defense practice.
Serving Baltimore & Surrounding Counties
Walsh-Little Law represents clients throughout the Baltimore metropolitan area in both state and federal courts.
Frequently Asked Questions: Grand Jury Subpoenas and Target Letters
Can my lawyer come into the grand jury room with me?
No. In federal court, only the government's attorneys, the witness being questioned, interpreters when needed and a court reporter may be present while the grand jury is in session, and Maryland Rule 4-642 contains a similar list for state grand juries. Under the Justice Department's Advice of Rights, a federal witness who has retained counsel is given a reasonable opportunity to step outside the room to consult with counsel.
What does it mean to receive a target letter?
Do I have to testify if I am subpoenaed?
Can I tell people that I testified before a grand jury?
Does Maryland use grand juries the same way federal courts do?
Contact a Baltimore Grand Jury Attorney Today, Free Consultation
A grand jury subpoena or a target letter generally arrives before any charge has been filed. Depending on the circumstances, there may be early decisions to make about testimony, documents and how to respond.
Call Walsh-Little Law today at 410-205-9337 for a free, confidential consultation. David will review your case, explain your options, and start building a defense from day one.
- Monday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Tuesday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Wednesday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Thursday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Friday 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
- Saturday Closed
- Sunday Closed
Email Us
We look forward to receiving your questions and comments and will reply to your email promptly.
* Required Field
"*" indicates required fields
Disclaimer: The Law Office of David Walsh-Little is a Maryland Limited Liability Company established for the practice of law. The information on this website is for general information only. The content on this site is not legal advice and should not be construed as such. Visitors to this site should not rely on its content when making legal decisions. Access to the information on this website is not intended to, and does not create, an attorney-client relationship between the Law Office of David Walsh-Little, LLC and any other person or entity.